Pissed off
In November 2024, I received an advertisement that read: We need to understand — voting will not save us. It went on to say that the talk would explore “the myth of voting as harm reduction.”
My blood boiled.
2025 and 2026 have been years of near-constant rage. I’m disappointed; I feel helpless; I’m energized; then the cycle continues. For the most part, my rage has been directed at the current administration and the never-ending barrage of evil, ridiculous nonsense it produces on the daily. But I have to admit that in the beginning, a lot of it was reserved for nonvoters.
I’d heard several conversations throughout the election cycle about the futility of voting, that “the Black man’s vote doesn’t matter anyway,” that the two parties are the same evil in slightly different fits, or that we just need to burn it all down.
I understand.
They’re rooted in a rightful disapproval for a government that has oppressed and disenfranchised Black, Brown, and poor folks for generations. The ideas drive some folks to apathy, and to disengage completely. Others follow the example of OG Black Radical activists like Malcolm X and encourage Black folks to withhold their votes until parties properly fight for our interests.
It’s true that both parties have committed atrocities and have proven, in many cases, to be untrustworthy. But almost two exhausting years into this presidency,
I can’t help but feel that anti-voting rhetoric was entirely unhelpful and even dangerous. It was ultimately a form of self-disenfranchisement that worked in fascists’ favor.
So Who’s To Blame?
A Pew Research Study concluded that Kamala Harris still would have lost if every nonvoter cast their vote for her. Swaths of folks pivoted from the Democrats and towards Donald Trump. So it’s unfair to place all of the responsibility for Trump’s second election on nonvoters because, factually, it wasn’t entirely their fault.
Institutions, elected officials, the rich and powerful, the punk-ass manosphere podcasters, and the outright Trump-supporting voters deserve the majority of the necessary smoke. All the non-voting in the world can’t negate stupidity, ignorance, or evil when they’re consistently present in the voting booths.
But non-voters and apathetic rhetoric aren’t blameless.
Voting as Strategy
Voting, especially in a two-party system like ours (an issue to discuss another day), is about strategy. It’s about recognizing how power works and how it impacts us—individualls and as a collective— in our daily lives. And, yes it can be harm reduction (absolutely not a myth). In this election, not voting reflected a lack of strategy, a lack of understanding of power, and a failure to act to protect the vulnerable.
In an IG video that perfectly explains this, content creator Dravon Rangel says,
“When I say that the system needs to be dismantled, I am not talking about blindly trusting a political party. I am talking about strategy…You do not throw away every imperfect tool available to you; because none of those tools alone can liberate us. Voting alone will not save us…Neither will protesting alone... You vote when voting can protect people… And you build something new by fighting like hell to protect people inside what currently exists… Because sometimes disengagement doesn’t punish the system; it abandons the people most vulnerable to what the system does next, and we are actively seeing that.”
Consequences
Many-a nonvoter has said they couldn’t cast a vote in good conscience for ethical reasons. But the decision not to vote isn’t without consequences and, therefore, arguably unethical in itself.
Where’s the “good conscience” when not voting means allowing the endangerment (and, in some cases, complete loss) of our privacy, rights, safety, access to public assistance programs, and environmental protections? When it means that the already unprotected—Black, Brown, poor, queer and rural folks in America and around the world—are put in increased danger?
As we’ve seen over and over the past year, not voting—and voting incorrectly—have collectively cost us financially, existentially, and politically. Many have lost access to Medicare; ICE has targeted, detained, and/or deported hundreds of thousands; gas prices have skyrocketed; wars have started and continued. Our democracy may have even been lost—we now have less influence, less political leverage, and less collective power to push back on the evils we’re seeing every day, and the administration has hinted that the next presidential election may not be held at all.
After the Trump administration’s cancellation of Affordable Care Act health insurance, Jamilah Lemieux posted on Threads, “One day, we’ll truly understand the resounding moral failure of ‘Both parties are bad so we won’t vote for either of them.’ Anyway, 750k folks lost their healthcare today.”
This understanding is exactly what we need to move into a new, healing chapter. And that understanding will only come from acknowledgement, radical accountability for the parts each of us played in this, togetherness, and the intentional decision to get off our asses and take collective political action.
Looking ahead…
New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani’s mayoral campaign and career are evidence of the power of tools—campaigning, grassroots organizing, and showing up to the polls—used in tandem. 100,000 volunteer canvassers put their boots on the ground, collectively knocking on 3 million doors. They transformed their frustration with the city’s politics into action that has brought positive political change.
Apathy will never pay off, but voting can. Change with voting (alongside other tools) is possible.
I’m sure you can probably read that there’s still some anger in my writing. But if the past few years have taught me anything, it’s that I need to lock tf in and get over it, because togetherness is the way forward. Division, hate, apathy, and skirted accountability have gotten us where we are today: nowhere good. We need mutual aid systems, political organization, independent support networks, canvassing/volunteering, and increased political education. We need cooperation and dialogue and understanding. I think that’s the way forward.
Voting alone won’t save us.
But voting as harm reduction is also not a myth. Showing up to the ballot box (or sending in your mail-in ballot!) are just the wrench and the hammer in the theoretical toolbox. But given the bullshit we’ve experienced since January 2025, I think we know now, all too well, that the cost of disengagement is too high not to show up. We’re in no position to throw out tools.
Bio: Nia Crichelle Robertson is an L.A.-based culture writer and grad student journalist who covers cultural institutions, cultural inheritance, and the influence of media on our identities.
IG: @crichelle.connects | Substack: Nia Crichelle
For just $5 a month, you’re directly investing in Black writers, Black ideas, and the future of independent Black media. Every subscription helps us commission original stories, platform new voices, and continue building E.N.D. into a living hub for revolutionary thought, culture, education, and community.
Thank you for helping us build something that belongs to us.



Go Vote some of remember what that means